Criminal and Legal Characteristics of Criminal Intent

  • Roman V. VERESHA The Academy of Advocacy, Kiev, Ukraine

Abstract

This paper considers the problems of the criminal and legal characteristics of criminal intent. The author analyzed the peculiar features of criminal intent as an element of mens rea. The conducted analysis allows stating that the criminal law of certain countries displays a tendency of mostly recognizing criminal intent not as an obligatory element of crimes. The paper substantiates the need for recognizing criminal intent as one of the elements of mens rea, which will allow determining the real intent of the crime and administering the appropriate type and amount of penalty. The study determined that criminal intent is a psychological phenomenon. Therefore, the issues of its analysis and study should be solved at levels, related to psychology and criminology, which will affect the research results, obtained within the framework of one scientific branch, and the setting of research questions and elaboration of conceptual elements regarding this subject in other scientific branches. The paper defines criminal intent, which should be viewed as substantial and outlined features of a conscious imaginary image of the future desired result, which determines the orientation and ordering of various types of criminal activity. Based on a scientific approach to the theoretical determination of intent in criminal law and its place in the mens rea of corpus delicti, the author suggests relating criminal intent to the optional elements of mens rea.

References

[1] Abdikerimova, A.A. 2016. Contemporary Development Trends in Administrative-Legal Relations in the System of Administrative Justice. International Journal of Environmental and Science Education, 11(11): 4782-4789.
[2] Anisimov, G.M., Dzyuba, Yu.P., and Kasynyuk V.I. 2011. Crimes against the Established Order of Military Service. Moscow: Law, 383.
[3] Ashmarina, S.I. et al. 2016. Methodical Bases for the Regional Information Potential Estimation. International Journal of Environmental and Science Education, 11(15): 7715-7725.
[4] Babanly, R.Sh., and Onishchuk, O.M. 2013. Mens Rea of the Crime of a Notary’s Abuse of Authority (Article 365-2 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine). Civil and Criminal Proceedings Journal, (2): 118–27.
[5] Babichev, A.G. 2013. Criminal Intent as an Element of a Murder Aggravation. The Review of Economy, the Law and Sociology, (4): 107–12.
[6] Bassiounim, M.C. 1978. Substantive Criminal Law. Springfield: Knowledge. 352.
[7] Baulin, Yu.V., Borysov, V.I., and Tyutyugin, V.I. 2010. Criminal Law of Ukraine. In V.V. Stashys and V.Ya. Tatsiy (Eds.). Kiev: Law. 263.
[8] Chernyshova, N.M. 2014. Characteristics of Mens Rea of Acquisitive Crime. Kherson State University Scientific Herald. Legal Sciences, 3(1): 101–5.
[9] Dangel, Е.М. 1951. Criminal Law. Boston: Spring. 352.
[10] De Jong, F. 2011. Theorizing Criminal Intent: A Methodological Account. Utrecht Law Review, 7: 17-22.
[11] Dorokhin, Yu.A. 2014. Mens Rea of Property Crimes. Legal Science, (4): 52–58.
[12] Dudorv, O.O., and Pysmennyi, Ye.O. 2012. Criminal Law (Special Part). Luhansk: Elton-2. 395
[13] Gora, I.Yu. 2014. The Mechanism of Antisocial Conduct Formation in Persons, Who Commit Crimes with Motives of Racial, National or Religious Intolerance. Legal Psychology and Pedagogy, (1): 183–92.
[14] Hart, H.A. 1968. Intention and Punishment. In Punishment and Responsibility: Essays in the Philosophy of Law. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 114.
[15] Holroyd, J. 2000. Smith & Hogan: Criminal Law Cases and Materials. Law teacher, 73: 366-378.
[16] Kas’ko, T.Yu. 2014. Mens Rea of Military Service Evasion by Self-Mutilation or Other Means. Legal Scientific Electronic Journal, (3): 112–14.
[17] Kastarnov, D.B. 2013. Influence of Mens Rea on the Classification of a Brutal Act. Scientific Legal Journal, (9): 51–60.
[18] Khar’, I.O. 2013a. Mens Rea and Its Influence on the Classification of a Brutal Act. Scientific Legal Journal, (4): 104–12.
[19] Khar’, I.O. 2013b. Mens Rea of the Crime, Indicated in Article 109 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Scientific Legal Journal, 11: 67–80.
[20] Krivtsov, A.I. et al. 2016. Corporate Information Management System and Its Influence on Increase of Changes Productivity. International Journal of Environmental and Science Education, 11(15): 7627-7636.
[21] Larina, O.V. 2012. Determining the Mens Rea of Robbery. Forum Prava, 3: 370–74.
[22] Lyska, P.O. 2014. Problematics and Gaps of the Disposition and Sanction of the Main Corpus Delecti, Provided by Article 307 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. International Journal ‘ScienceRise’ 1 Legal Sc, (1): 114–26.
[23] Masol, D.I. 2013. Criminal and Legal Meaning of Criminal Motive. European Prospects, (11): 67–74.
[24] McKinney`s. 2012 Consolidated Laws of New York. New York: Springer. 246.
[25] Michael, J., and Reitz, J.D. 2013. Criminal Minds: Defining Culpability in Michigan Criminal Law. Texas Public Policy Foundation, 2: 144-157.
[26] Mishchuk, I.P. 2014. Criminal Law. General Provisions. In I.P. Mishchuk (Eds.). Kiev: Criminal and Penal Service Institute. 375.
[27] Naumov, A.V. 2010. Russian Criminal Law: Lecture Course. Moscow: Wolters Kluwer. 364.
[28] Orlov, Yu.V. 2011. Motive as an Element of Mens Rea: The Essence and Question of Legislative Enshrinement Expediency. Law and Safety, 4(41): 116–20.
[29] Orobets, K.M. 2014. Lucri Causa: The Concept, Main Types and Criminal and Legal Meaning. Criminal Law Association of Ukraine Bulletin, 2(3): 69–74.
[30] Orzhynska, E.I. 2013. The Content of Criminal Activity Elements. Dnipropetrovsk State University of Internal Affairs Scientific Bulletin, (1): 607–13.
[31] Parker, J.S. 1993. The Economics of Mens Rea. Virginia Law Review, 4(79): 741.
[32] Parsons, S. 2004. Intention in Criminal Law. Mountbatten Journal of Legal Studies, 5: 11–19.
[33] Pashchenko, A.O. 2015. The Crime of Genocide according to the Criminal Code of Ukraine and the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. In Promising Areas of Development of the Modern Legal Science, 5: 86–88.
[34] Pavlykivskyi, V.I. 2014. Intent as an Obligatory Element of Prevention in Legal Professional Activity of Journalists. Kherson State University Scientific Herald. Legal Sciences, 3(3): 80–84.
[35] Rengier, R, and Rengier, S.B. 1998. Strafrecht Besonderer Teil die Person und Allgemeinheit. Belin: Auflage: 534.
[36] Roulston, R.P. 1975. Introduction to Criminal Law in New South Wales. Sydnеу: Butterworths. 255.
[37] Sakhno, R.I. 2013. Determining the Mens Rea of Violation of the Right of Defense (Article 374 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine). Science and Law Enforcement, 2(20): 118–23.
[38] Semykina, L.O. 2013. ‘Mens Rea of Extortion.’ European Prospects, (4): 112–18.
[39] Sigler, J.A. 1981. Understanding Criminal Law. Boston: Spring. 452.
[40] Smith, J.C. 1995. Criminal Evidence. Sweet & Maxwell, 1: 155-167.
[41] Steblynska, O.S. 2014. Criminal Law. Special Part. Kiev: Criminal and Penal Service Institute. 285.
[42] Streltsov, Ye.L. 2012. The Criminal Code of Ukraine: Scientific and Practical Commentary. Kharkov: Odissey. 263.
[43] Thomas, C.W., and Bishop, D.M. 1987. Criminal Law: Understanding Basic Principles. New York: Sage publications. 317.
[44] Veresha, R.V. 2012. Criminal Law of Ukraine. General Part. Guide. Kiev: Educational Literature Center, 364.
Published
2017-03-06
How to Cite
VERESHA, Roman V.. Criminal and Legal Characteristics of Criminal Intent. Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, [S.l.], v. 7, n. 7, p. 1881-1890, mar. 2017. ISSN 2068-696X. Available at: <https://journals.aserspublishing.eu/jarle/article/view/782>. Date accessed: 20 apr. 2024.