Comparative Analysis of Foundations of Legal Regulation of Criminal Liability for Organ Trafficking in the Russian Federation, Kazakhstan, and the European Union

  • Anna V. SEREBRENNIKOVA Department of Criminal Law and Criminology, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russian Federation
  • Tatjana F. MINYASEVA Department of Criminal Law and Criminology, Moscow Academy of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation, Moscow, Russian Federation
  • Nagima S. KALA Department of International Law, L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University, Nur-Sultan, Kazakhstan
  • Alexei A. MALINOVSKY Department of Theory of Law and Comparative Law, Moscow State Institute of International Relations (MGIMO University), Moscow, Russian Federation
  • Victoria M. MALINOVSKAYA Department of Criminal Law, Criminal Process and Criminalistics, Moscow State Institute of International Relations (MGIMO University), Moscow, Russian Federation
  • Serhii V. GRYNCHAK Department of Criminal Law No 1, Institute of Prosecutor's Office and Criminal Justice, Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University, Kharkiv, Ukraine

Abstract

Currently, organ trafficking occupies a leading position among transnational organized criminal groups due to the high demand for illegal services and the relatively low rates of detection of illegal actions by law enforcement agencies. In this context, the purpose of the paper was to conduct a comparative analysis of the foundations of the legal regulation of criminal liability for organ trafficking and trafficking in the Russian Federation, Kazakhstan, and the European Union to form scientifically substantiated conclusions and suggestions for improving existing national legislation. To achieve this purpose, general scientific and special methods were used. The study also uncovers vectors and substantiates the feasibility of implementing EU legislation in the field of organ trafficking and trafficking in the criminal legislation of the Russian Federation and Kazakhstan, predicts the prospects for improving legal regulation on the subject matter and outlined the priority actions of legislative bodies. At the same time, promising areas of research in this matter are the issues of punishability of such acts and the appointment of the appropriate punishment. Furthermore, the creation of a highly regulated transplantation system at the national level was proposed, which is to be managed by a national transplantation authority with broad oversight powers. The creation of such a centralised competent authority will ensure the implementation of the scope of measures that would effectively reduce the risk of organ trafficking and trafficking and protect potential victims.

References

[1] Additional Protocol to the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine concerning Transplantation of Organs and Tissues of Human Origin. 2002. https://rm.coe.int/1680081581.
[2] Ambagtsheer, F. 2020. Combating human trafficking for the purpose of organ removal: lessons learned from prosecuting criminal cases. In: Winterdyk J., Jones J. (Eds), The Palgrave International Handbook of Human Trafficking. Palgrave Macmillan.
[3] Bigwawa, Z.K. (Ed.). 2002. Criminal Code of Georgia. Legal Center ‘Press’.
[4] Budiani-Saberi, D.A., Raja, K.R., and Findley, K.C. 2014. Human trafficking for organ removal in India: A victim-centred, evidence-based report. Transplantation 12(3): 380-384.
[5] Columb, S. 2016. Excavating the organ trade: an empirical study of organ trading networks in Cairo, Egypt. British Journal of Criminology 57(6): 1301-1321.
[6] Convention for the protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine: Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine. 1997. https://www.coe.int/ru/web/conventions/full-list/-/conventions/treaty/164.
[7] Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings. 2005. https://rm.coe.int/16805a937a.
[8] Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs. 2014. https://search.coe.int/cm/Pages/result_details.aspx?ObjectID=09000016805c53a2.
[9] Council of Europe Recommendation. 2004. https://www.coe.int/t/dg3/healthbioethic/Activities/08_Psychiatry_and_human_rights_en/Rec(2004)10%20EM%20E.pdf.
[10] Cronin, A.J., et al. 2011. Solving the kidney transplant crisis for minority ethnic groups in the UK: is being transplanted overseas the answer? In: W. Weimar, M.A. Bos, J.J. Busschbach (Eds.), Organ Transplantation: Ethical, Legal and Psychosocial Aspects Expanding the European Platform, 62-72. Pabst Science Publishers.
[11] De Jong, J. 2017. Human trafficking for the purpose of organ removal. Utrecht University.
[12] Directive 2010/45/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 7 July 2010 on standards of quality and safety of human organs intended for transplantation.2010.Official Journal of the European Union.https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?qid=1588254441385&uri=CELEX:32010L0053.
[13] Directive 2010/53/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 7 July 2010 on standards of quality and safety of human organs intended for transplantation. 2010. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eudr/2010/53.
[14] Directive 2011/36/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 5 April 2011 on preventing and combating trafficking in human beings and protecting its victims, and replacing Council Framework Decision 2002/629/JHA. 2011. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32011L0036.
[15] Dorfman, M. 2000. Transplantation of human organs and tissues from the standpoint of Israeli law. https://pravo.israelinfo.co.il/articles/analitik/389?print.
[16] Dronova, S.A. 2018. Protection of human rights and dignity in organ donation and transplantation: a comparative legal approach. Constitutional and Municipal Law 4: 66-71.
[17] Gill, J.S., et al. 2010. Policy statement of Canadian society of transplantation and Canadian society of nephrology on organ trafficking and transplant tourism. Transplantation 90(8): 817-820.
[18] Guiding Principles on Human Cell, Tissue and Organ Transplantation. 2010. World Health Organization. https://www.who.int/transplantation/Guiding_PrinciplesTransplantation_WHA63.22ru.pdf.
[19] Human Organ Transplants Act. 1989. http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1989/ukpga_19890031_en_1.
[20] Kapitonova, E.A., Romanovskaya, O.V., and Romanovsky, G.B. 2016. Legal regulation of transplantology. Prospect.
[21] Kuznetsova, N.F., and Reshetnikov, F.M. 1998. Criminal Code of Spain. Zertsalo.
[22] Lukashov, A.I. (Ed.). 2001. Criminal Code of the Republic of Latvia. Legal Center ‘Press’.
[23] Mahdavi-Mazdeh, M. 2012. The Iranian model of living renal transplantation. Kidney International 82(6): 627 634.
[24] Martin, D.E., et al. 2019. Strengthening global efforts to combat organ trafficking and transplant tourism: implications of the 2018 Edition of the Declaration of Istanbul.Transplantation Direct 5(3): art. No. 433. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30882038.
[25] Merion,R.M., et al. 2008. Transplants in foreign countries among patients removed from the US transplant waiting list. American Journal of Transplantation 8: 988-996.
[26] Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on the sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography. 2000. https://www.un.org/ru/documents/decl_conv/conventions/rightschild_protocol2.shtml.
[27] Organised Crime, Arms Trafficking, and Illicit Financial Flows: Exploring SDG Target 16.4. 2019. https://gfintegrity.org/event/organized-crime-arms-trafficking-and-illicit-financial-flows-exploring-sdg-target-16-4/.
[28] Scheper-Hughes, N. 2013. Organ trafficking: a protected crime. The Conversation. http://theconversation.com\organ-trafficking-a-protected-crime-16178.
[29] Sharif, A., Singh, M.F., Trey, T., and Lavee, J. 2014. Organ procurement from executed prisoners in China. American Journal of Transplantation 14(10): 2246-2252.
[30] Smirnov, V.A. 2011. Murder in order to use the organs and (or) tissues of the victim: historical law research. Siberian Legal Bulletin 1: 103-110.
[31] Strengthening and promoting effective measures and international cooperation on organ donation and transplantation to prevent and combat trafficking in persons for the purpose of organ removal and trafficking in human organs. 2017. United Nations General Assembly. https://undocs.org/pdf?symbol=ru/A/71/L.80.
[32] The Criminal Code of Kazakhstan. 1997. https://online.zakon.kz/document/?doc_id=1008032.
[33] The Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. 1996. http://www.interlaw.ru/law/docs/10008000/.
[34] The History and Development of the Declaration of Istanbul. Declaration of Istanbul on Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism. 2014. https://www.declarationofistanbul.org/about-the-declaration/history-and-development.
[35] Tong, A., et al. 2012. The experiences of commercial kidney donors: thematic synthesis of qualitative research. Transplant International 25(11): 1138 1149.
[36] Transplantation: frequently asked questions.2019. Frequently asked questions answered by the head of the Moscow Coordination Centre for Organ Donation (MCCOD) at the Botkin Hospital n.a. M.G. Minin. https://botkinmoscow.ru/info/otdel/otdelenie-transplantacii-organov-20/transplantaciya-chasto-zadavaemye-voprosy/.
[37] Vertrag über die Arbeitsweise der Europäischen Union (Konsolidierte Fassung). 2012. Amtsblatt der Europäischen Union. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:12012E/TXT:de:PDF.
[38] Yousaf, F.N., and Purkayastha, B. 2015. ‘I am only half alive’: organ trafficking in Pakistan amid interlocking oppressions. International Sociology 30(6): 637-653.
[39] Zhalinskaya-Roericht, A.A. 2001. Law of the Federal Republic of Germany on organ transplantation in 1997: constitutional and criminal law consequences. Law and Politics 7: 94-101.
[40] Zharikov,S. 2018. Kazakhstanis will be able to register their refusal from a posthumous donation in 2019. https://www.interfax.kz/?lang=rus&int_id=13&news_id=360.
Published
2020-06-15
How to Cite
SEREBRENNIKOVA, Anna V. et al. Comparative Analysis of Foundations of Legal Regulation of Criminal Liability for Organ Trafficking in the Russian Federation, Kazakhstan, and the European Union. Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, [S.l.], v. 11, n. 4, p. 1405 – 1415, june 2020. ISSN 2068-696X. Available at: <https://journals.aserspublishing.eu/jarle/article/view/5345>. Date accessed: 09 aug. 2020. doi: https://doi.org/10.14505/jarle.v11.4(50).37.