Discussion on Criminalization of Corporate Liability in the Russian Federation

  • A.V. SHASHKOVA Department of Constitutional Law, Moscow State University of International Relations (MGIMO – University), Moscow Region Bar Lawyer, Honorary Consul for St. Vincent and the Grenadines, Russian Federation

Abstract

The goal of the present research is to formulate scientifically grounded suggestions on the issue of criminalization of corporate liability in Russia. The article focuses on different theoretical approaches towards establishing corporate criminal liability in national legislature of the Russian Federation. The article focuses on the roots and evolution of the problem of introducing criminal corporate liability, analyses arguments pro et contra corporate criminal liability as an instrument of prevention and combat against corporate and other forms of white-collar crime, particularities of implementation of criminal liability for corporations to the legislation of the Russian Federation. The article analyses such symbolic court precedents as those elaborated in cases ‘Santa Clara County v. Southern Pacific Railroad Co.’ in the USA and ‘Salomon v. Salomon & Co. Ltd’. in the UK. The problem of the emergency of the idea of criminalization of corporate responsibility is analyzed from historical point of view with application of the historical method and of the object of the analysis method. Some public-private research methods are also used: formally-logical or comparative legal method are used to compare decisions of different courts on the same precedent. The central part of the article examines different theoretical and practical views on introduction of corporate liability in general and in the Russian Federation in particular. The author aims to shed light on different dimensions of the matter, pointing to interdependency of various aspects.  The analysis of the historical roots of the problem of liability of corporations, introduction of different types of liability in foreign countries, analysis of the position of the civil society and the state bodies in the Russian Federation gives a ground for further elaboration together with the professional society on the problem of necessity of criminal liability for corporations in the Russian Federation to find optimal solution.

References

[1] Bequali, A. 1978. White Collar Crime: A 20th Century Crisis. Lexington Books. Lexington, Massachusetts.
[2] Bloch, R. 2013. Corporations and the Fourteenth Amendment. UCLA. 64 p.
[3] Buell, S.W. 2017. The Responsibility Gap in Corporate Crime. Criminal Law and Philosophy. 1 - 21 p.
[4] Buell, S.W. 2016. Capital Offenses: Business Crime and Punishment in America's Corporate Age. W.W. Norton. 296 p.
[5] Bytko, J. 2015. Nuzhen li Rossii takoj zakon (k voprosu o proekte zakona ob ugolovnoj otvetstvennosti juridicheskih lic). [Does Russia Need Such a Law (to the Problem of the Draft Law on Criminal Responsibility of Legal Ebtities)]. Saratovskaja gosudarstvennaja juridicheskaja akademija. 2 (103). p. 182-193 (In Russ.).
[6] Cleveland, M., Favo, C., Frecka, T., and Owens, C. 2010. Trends in the International Fight Against Bribery and Corruption. Journal of Business Ethics. 199 – 244 p.
[7] Croal, H. 2013. Victims of White-Collar and Corporate Crime. Matters of Russian and International Law. N. 3. 84 p.
[8] Dignam A. Company Law. Oxford University Press. 2011. 101 p.
[9] Duff, A., Farmer, L., Marshall, S., Renzo, M., and Tadros V. 2014. Criminalization. The Political Morality of the Criminal Law. Oxford University Press. 312 p.
[10] Etudaiyae-Muhtar, O., Ahmad, R., and Matemilola, B. 2017. Corporate Debt Maturity Structure: The Role of the Firm Level and Institutional Determinants in Selected African Countries. Global Economic Review. 1-19 p.
[11] Fedorov, A. 2017. Pravovaja ohrana korporativnyh otnoshenij. Aktual'nye problemy, protivodejstvie sovremennym kriminal'nym ugrozam, zarubezhnyj opyt [Legal security of corporate relations. Current problems, confrontation with relevant means, foreign experience]. Justicinform. 1070 p.
[12] Golubtsov, V., and Kunznetsov O. 2013. Russian Federation as the Subject of the Civil Liability. World Applied Sciences Journal. N. 24 (1). 31 - 34 p.
[13] Grantham, R. 1998. Corporate personality in the 20th Century. Hart Publishing. Oxford. 295 p.
[14] Greenberg, J., and Brotman, E. 2014.Corporate Culture in the Context of Corporate Crimes Prevention. American Criminal Law Review. 51(1). 79-98 p.
[15] Grimes, J. 2013. Fourth statutory corporate manslaughter conviction – are trends emerging? Kingsley Napley. URL: https://www.kingsleynapley.co.uk/insights/blogs/criminal-law-blog/fourth-statutory-corporate-manslaughter-conviction-are-trends-emerging (Accessed 27.10.2017).
[16] Hagan, F. 2010. Introduction to Criminology: Theories, Methods, and Criminal Behavior. SAGE Publications, Inc. Seventh Edition. 576 p.
[17] Kosolapov, N. 2011. Gosudarstvo kak korporacija i korporacija kak gosudarstvo: produkt globalizacii ili novaja fenomenologija? [A State as a Corporationa and a Corporation as a State: Product of Globalization or New Fenomenology?] Sravnitel'naja politika. N. 2. 19 p. (In Russ.)].
[18] Lerner, C. 2017. The Trial of Joseph Dotterweich: Origins of the ‘Responsible Corporate Officer’ Doctrine. Criminal Law and Philosophy. 1 - 20 p.
[19] McGrath, J. 2017. Instrumental and Expressive Governance, Corporate and White-Collar Crime in Contemporary Society. Law and Financial Markets Review. 1 - 9 p.
[20] Mankoff, M. 1972. The poverty in progress: The political economy of American social problems. Holt, Rinehart and Winston. 524 p.
[21] Marx, K., and Engels F. Gesamtausgabe (The Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844). M. Institute of Marxism-Leninism in Moscow. Abt. 1. Bd. 3. 1932.
[22] Marx, K., and Engels, F. 2004. The German Ideology. N.Y.: International Publishers. 571 p.
[23] Pearce, F. 1992. The contribution of ‘left realism’ to the study of commercial crime. B. McLean and J. Lowman (eds), Realist Criminology: Crime Control and Policing in the 1990s. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 384 p.
[24] Ramirez, M.K., and Ramirez, S.A. 2017. The Case for the Corporate Death Penalty: Restoring Law and Order on Wall Street. NYU Press. 288 p.
[25] Shashkova, A.V. 2011. Financial and Legal Aspects of Doing Business in Russia. Aspect-Press. 256 p.
[26] Shashkova, A.V. 2015. Study Manual on Bases of Russian Law. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. 374 p.
[27] Shashkova, A.V. 2015. Kriminalizacija korporativnoj otvetstvennosti [Criminalization of Corporate Responsibility]. Politics, the State and the Law. n. 8 (44) 17.
[28] Shashkova, A.V. Russian Corporate Law. – M.: Lincor. – P. 330.
[29] Shashkova, A.V. 2017. Rakittskaya, I.A., and Pavlov, E.Ya. Emergence and Activity of Legal Entities in Russia in the Pre-Revolutionary Period (comparative analysis), in Bylye Gody, Vol. 46, Is. 4, pp. 1333-1344.
[30] Schumpeter, J. 2008. The Theory of Economic Development: An Inquiry into Profits, Capital, Credit, Interest and the Business Cycle (first published in 1934). 244 p.
[31] Whelan, P. 2014. The Criminalization of European Cartel Enforcement. Theoretical, Legal, and Practical Challenges. Oxford University Press. 391 p.
Published
2019-09-30
How to Cite
SHASHKOVA, A.V.. Discussion on Criminalization of Corporate Liability in the Russian Federation. Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, [S.l.], v. 10, n. 5, p. 1525-1533, sep. 2019. ISSN 2068-696X. Available at: <https://journals.aserspublishing.eu/jarle/article/view/4840>. Date accessed: 29 feb. 2024.