Legal Problems of Using ‘Extremist Motives’ in Crimes Against Life and Health

  • Dinara GOSTKOVA Chelyabinsk State University, Chelyabinsk, Russian Federation
  • Mikhail KOSTYUK Plekhanov Russian University of Economics, Moscow, Russian Federation
  • Elena KUNTS Chelyabinsk State University, Chelyabinsk, Russian Federation

Abstract

The relevance of the paper is conditioned by the varying interpretations and use of the qualifying element ‘from motives of political, ideological, racial, national or religious hatred or enmity or from hatred or enmity motives towards a social group’ in the Russian criminal law theory and law enforcement practice. The objective of the research is to develop proposals on improvement of the qualifying element and recommendations for its use in crimes against life and health according to the Russian Federation Criminal Code. The methods applied by the authors are dialectical knowledge acquisition method, comparative legal method as well as special ones: formal legal, statistical, sociological, and systemic method. The study has shown that it is rarely if ever that the content of the extremist motive of crimes against life and health is discussed. The notions of hatred and enmity are not identical categories, and they should not be used simultaneously in law enforcement practice in relation to one and the same act. Despite the fact that the content of hostility, as a rule, covers the concept of hatred, doctrinal proposals for the deletion of the last term from the structure of the qualifying element are untenable. Since the guilty person can act for the purpose of provoking enmity and not experience hateful feelings. As the structure of the ‘extremist motive’ was more complicated, further difficulties emerged, in particular, the varying interpretation of political, ideological hatred or enmity and social group. In order to resolve the outlined problems, it is suggested to exclude the notion of ‘social group’ from the qualifying element under consideration.

References

[1] Buzan, B. 1991. People, States and Fear. An Agenda for International Security Studies in the Post-Cold War Era. New York-London: Harvester Wheatsheaf: 393.
[2] Chernova, D.A. 2015. On the question of criminological characteristic of crimes of an extremist orientation in Russia. European Journal of Law and Political Sciences, 2, 34-37.
[3] Coppieters, B. 1996. Contested Borders in the Caucasus. Brussels: VUBPress: 205.
[4] Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. 1996. http://base.garant.ru/10108000/ (accessed November 18, 2017).
[5] Dikusar, Ya.S., and Oskoeva, S.V. 2015. Problems of qualifying a murder from the motives of national hatred and enmity (item ‘k’ part 2 article 105 of the RF CC) depending on the object of crime and the victim. Aspirant, 4(9), 151-153.
[6] Federal Law of the Russian Federation No. 211-FZ of July 24, 2007 ‘On the Introduction of Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation in Connection with the Improvement of Public Administration in the Sphere of Countering Extremism’ (as amended and supplemented). http://base.garant.ru/12154849/ (accessed September 20, 2017).
[7] Galtung, J. 1981. Western civilization: anatomy and pathology. Alternatives: Global, Local, Political, 7, 145-169.
[8] Golubovskii, V.Y., Kazhkeeva, B.S., Kunts, E.V., and Rasbaeva, A.B. 2016. Historical and legal study of the national equality protection in the Russian legislation. Indian Journal of Science and Technology, 9(19). http://csu.kz/scop/%D0%9A%D0%B0%D0%B6%D0%BA%D0%BA%D0%B5%D0%B5%D0%B2%D0%B0%20%D0%91.%D0%A1.%20%D0%A1%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BF%D1%83%D1%812016.pdf (accessed December 20, 2017).
[9] Hall, N. 2005. Hate Crime. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.
[10] Huntington, S. 1993. The clash of civilizations. Foreign Affairs, 3, 22-49.
[11] Ivanov, A. 2015. Questions of qualifying a murder committed on an extremist motive (item ‘k’ part 2 article 105 of the RF CC). Criminal Law, 3, 41-45.
[12] Jacobs, J.B., and Potter, K. 1998. Hate Crimes. Criminal Law and Identity Politics. New York: Oxford University Press: 224.
[13] Kolchedantsev, A.G. 2012. A Brief Explanatory Dictionary of the Special Part of the Russian Federation Criminal Code. Chelyabinsk: Chelyabinsk State University Publishing House.
[14] Kunashev, A.A. 2010. Qualification of crimes against person committed from the motives of hatred or enmity combined with other motives. Bulletin of the Academy of the Russian Federation General Prosecutor Office, 2(16), 46-49.
[15] Kunashev, A.A. 2012. Motives of Hatred or Enmity in the Criminal Law of Russia. Moscow: Academy of the Russian Federation General Prosecutor Office: 21.
[16] Kuntz, Y.V., and Golubovskiy, V.Y. 2015. The legal nature of ethnic and religious conflicts. Indian Journal of Science and Technology, 8(10), 1-7.
[17] Mikaelyan, N.G. 2012. The topical aspects of murders from motives of political, ideological, racial, national or religious hatred or enmity or from hatred or enmity motives towards a social group. The Legal Bulletin of Dagestan State University, 4, 81-85.
[18] Panasenko, S.N. 2012. Criminal liability for murders committed from motives of political, ideological, racial, national or religious hatred or enmity or from hatred or enmity motives towards a social group (item ‘k’ part 2 article 105 of the RF CC). Moscow: A.S. Griboedov Institute of International Law and Economics.
[19] Resolution of the Plenum of the RF Supreme Court No. 11 of June 28, 2011. ‘On judicial practice in criminal cases of extremist nature crimes’. http://xn--b1azaj.xn--p1ai/2011/postanovlenie-plenuma-vs-rf/N11-ot-28.06.2011.html (accessed September 15, 2017).
[20] Resolution of the Plenum of the RF Supreme Court No. 45 of November 15, 2007. ‘On judicial practice in criminal cases of hooliganism and other crimes committed from molester motives’. http://www.garant.ru/products/ipo/prime/doc/12057133/ (accessed October 9, 2017).
[21] Rustamov, N.E. 2015. Criminal Law and criminological characteristics of murders from motives of political, ideological, racial, national or religious hatred or enmity or from hatred or enmity motives towards a social group. Moscow: People's Friendship University of Russia.
[22] Savelyeva, O.Yu. 2009. Liability for willful infliction of grievous bodily harm from motives of political, ideological, racial, national or religious hatred or enmity or from hatred or enmity motives towards a social group. Vector of Science of Togliatti State University, 5, 111-114.
[23] Solovyeva, S.V. 2014. Crimes committed on the grounds of hatred or enmity: the questions of qualification, penalization and assignment of punishment. Krasnodar: Kuban State Agrarian University.
[24] Trukhachev, V.V., and Akhmedov, U.N. 2015. The concept of extremizm in the criminal law of the Russian Federation. Proceedings of Voronezh State University, 2, 176-184.
[25] Veliev, F.Z. 2015. Motive of hatred or enmity and its criminal law significance. Moscow: O.E. Kutafin Moscow State Legal University.
[26] Volkov, B.S. 1982. Motives of crimes. Kazan: Kazan University Publishing House: 152.
Published
2018-12-22
How to Cite
GOSTKOVA, Dinara; KOSTYUK, Mikhail; KUNTS, Elena. Legal Problems of Using ‘Extremist Motives’ in Crimes Against Life and Health. Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, [S.l.], v. 9, n. 3(33), p. 949-955, dec. 2018. ISSN 2068-696X. Available at: <https://journals.aserspublishing.eu/jarle/article/view/2544>. Date accessed: 22 aug. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.14505//jarle.v9 3(33).19.