Historical Aspects of the Formation of the Jury Trial in Russia

  • Natalya Viktorovna BUSHNAYA Stavropol Branch of the Moscow State Pedagogical University, Stavropol, Russian Federation
  • Elena Anatolyevna PERSHINA Stavropol Branch of the Moscow State Pedagogical University, Stavropol, Russian Federation
  • Oksana Vasilyevna KABAKOVA Stavropol Branch of the Moscow State Pedagogical University, Stavropol, Russian Federation
  • Galina Viktorovna STANKEVICH Stavropol Branch of the Moscow State Pedagogical University, Stavropol, Russian Federation
  • Anzhelika Arslanovna CHUNIKHA Stavropol Branch of the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Stavropol, Russian Federation


The relevance of the scientific analysis of the formation of the jury trial is due to the processes of updating the legal system, which are extremely complex and contradictory in legal, political and social aspects. The reform of the judicial system affects the most important areas – economic, social, political, and legal ones. Therefore, it becomes necessary to comprehend the rich theoretical and practical historical experience of Russia.

The complexity of the processes of transformation of Russian statehood makes certain demands – a judicial reform should be theoretically justified both in the context of the traditions of Russian legal doctrines, which will allow proposing new approaches to the study of a legal doctrine, and in the context of the general theory of law, the methodology of which will allow using doctrines of the past for modern research of state-legal phenomena.

The authors pursued the goal of revealing the features of the genesis of the jury trial in the conditions of the judicial reform of the second half of the nineteenth century. Such cognition methods as historical, comparative-legal, system-structural, logical, formal-legal ones have been used to achieve this goal.

During the study, the authors made a conclusion that the historical aspect of the formation and development of the jury trial in Russia created prerequisites for analyzing the ʼadvantagesʼ and ʼdisadvantagesʼ of this form of legal proceedings in modern conditions.

The novelty of the stated area of research is that within its framework, the problems and trends of interaction of Russian juridical science and the reform process in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries have been analyzed, and this is of great practical and scientific importance. The article focuses on considering the accumulated rich historical experience in order to identify the facets of the interface of juridical science and practice, determine the extent of its influence on the government direction of reforms, the ability to put the achieved level of gained knowledge to good use and respond to the social order of the time. Modern jurisprudence plays the same role; therefore, it is necessary to identify the problems that Russian legal scholars faced in the nineteenth century in order to avoid them now and in future, which is the aim of this research project. Therefore, the article is a comprehensive analysis of the trends of interaction and interdependence of juridical science and the process of in-depth reforming of the Russian state in the second half of the nineteenth century by the example of the formation of the jury trial.


[1] Demichev, A.A. 2003. Sravnitelno-pravovoe issledovanie suda prisyazhnykh v Rossii: istoriya i sovremennost: Avtoreferat diss. dokt. yurid. nauk [Comparative-Law Research of the Jury in Russia: History and Modernity (Doctoral Thesis Abstract). The Nizhniy Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, Nizhniy Novgorod.
[2] Grigoriev, V.N, Pobedkin, A.V., and Yashin, V.N. 2006. Ugolovnyi protsess [Criminal Process]. Moscow: Publishing house EKSMO.
[3] Ilyukhov, A.A. 2009. Sud prisyazhnykh v Rossii: istoricheskie, ugolovnoprotsessual'nye i ugolovno-pravovye aspekty [Jury Trial in Russia: Historical, Criminal Procedural and Criminal Law Aspects]. Moscow: Moscow University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, the Smolensk Branch.
[4] Koni, A.F. 1890. Sudebnye rechi 1868-1888. Obvinitelnye rechi. Rukovodyashchie naputstviya prisyazhnym. Kassatsionnye zaklyucheniya [Courtroom Speech as of 1868-1888. Indictments. Guiding Requests to the Jury. Opinions of the Court of Cassation]. St. Petersburg: Piter.
[5] Koni, A.F. 1969. Sobranie sochinenii [Collected Works] (Vol. 8). Moscow: Yuridicheskaya literatura.
[6] Konin, V.V. 2011. Konstitutsionno-pravovaya priroda suda s uchastiem prisyazhnykh zasedatelei kak odnogo iz institutov grazhdanskogo obshchestva [Constitutional-Legal Nature of the Court with the Participation of the Jury Trial as One of the Civil Society Institutions]. Rossiiskaya yustitsiya, 3, 21-29.
[7] Novikov, E.S. 2011. Vvedenie suda prisyazhnykh v Stavropolskoi gubernii [The Introduction of the Jury Trial in the Stavropol Governorate]. https://superinf.ru/view_helpstud.php?id=1770. (accessed November 10, 2017).
[8] Popova, A.D. 2010. Sud prisyazhnykh kak atribut demokraticheskogo gosudarstva: istoriya i sovremennost [Jury as an Attribute of a Democratic State: History and Modernity]. Rossiiskaya yustitsiya, 5, 56-59.
[9] Unkovskiy, A.M. 1974. Soobrazheniya po dokladam Redaktsionnykh komissii [Considerations on the Reports of the Editorial Commissions]. In Golosa iz Rossii. Sborniki A.I. Gertsena i P.I. Ogareva [Voices from Russia. Collections by A.I. Herzen and P.I. Ogarev] (3rd ed., Book 9). Moscow: Nauka.
[10] Zarudny, S.I. 1879. Obshchie soobrazheniya o sostave suda [General Considerations on the Composition of the Court]. St. Petersburg: Piter.
[11] Zozulya, I.V. 1999. Sud prisyazhnykh zasedatelei na Stavropole [Jury trial in the Stavropol region]. In Problemy arkheologii i istorii Severnogo Kavkaza: Materialy nauchno-etnograficheskoi, istoriko-kraevedcheskoi konferentsii ʼII Minaevskie chteniyaʼ (13 marta 1998) [Problems of Archeology And History of the North Caucasus: Materials of the Scientific-Ethnographic, Regional Natural History Conference ʼII Minaevsky Readingsʼ (March 13, 1998)]. Stavropol.
How to Cite
BUSHNAYA, Natalya Viktorovna et al. Historical Aspects of the Formation of the Jury Trial in Russia. Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, [S.l.], v. 9, n. 1, p. 58-64, sep. 2018. ISSN 2068-696X. Available at: <https://journals.aserspublishing.eu/jarle/article/view/2285>. Date accessed: 25 feb. 2024. doi: https://doi.org/10.14505//jarle.v9.1(31).08.